Skip navigation
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
Title: Pragmatic Norms in Science. Making Them Explicit
Authors: Caamaño, Alegre
Issue Date: 2013
Publisher: Springer
Citation: Synthese, 190, 15, 3227-3246
Abstract: The present work constitutes an attempt to make explicit those pragmatic norms successfully operating in empirical science. I will first comment on the initial presuppositions of the discussion, in particular, on those concerning the instrumental character of scientific practice and the nature of scientific goals. Then I will depict the moderately naturalistic frame in which, from this approach, the pragmatic norms make sense. Third, I will focus on the specificity of the pragmatic norms, making special emphasis on what I regard as a key idea underlying them, namely, the view, vigorously advocated by classical pragmatists like C. S. Peirce and G. Vailati, that the best test for objectivity is the test of action. Finally, I am going to put forward a tentative list of pragmatic norms that can be abstracted from a careful observation and analysis of scientific practice as provided by current philosophers of experimentation (A. Franklin and F. Steinle among others). The norms will be divided into four classes corresponding to four aspects of science in which they rule, that is, self-correction, prediction, explanation and both experimentation and computation. In the following account, the formulation of those pragmatic norms successfully governing science will be understood as a contribution that scientifically-oriented pragmatism can make to the normative naturalistic project in epistemology.
Peer Review: SI
Sponsor: Language and Thought: Context-Dependency (FFI2008-06421- CO2-02/FISO), Cognitive Attitudes and the Justification of Knowledge (FFI2009- 08828/FISO), “La pragmática como dinamizadora del estudio de la flexibilidad semántica: contextos conversacionales y contextos teóricos” (FFI2012-33881)
Rights Owner: Springer
Language: eng
Rights: info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess
Appears in Collections:DEP28 - Artículos de revista

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
NormFinal.pdf204,09 kBAdobe PDFThumbnail

Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.

University of Valladolid
Powered by MIT's. DSpace software, Version 5.5